Key Takeaways

  1. One big takeaway from this class is that a lot of the books we see being banned are ones from diverse perspectives that do not align with the traditional, white male-dominated, hetero-normative standards of society. It seems as if a lot of these bannings come from a place of fear of change and a fear of elevating the voices that our society has squashed from the start. People do not want to acknowledge the privilege that some carry and how that has shaped the world we see today, and many feel that this can be brought up through conversations surrounding these banned books. Overall, I think it is important to really analyze a text and its reasons for being banned in order to get to the heart of the argument being made because it is much deeper than just banning books.
  2. A second takeaway is to evaluate who is really affected by banning these books. It is one thing to have a book be banned and to assess and acknowledge why it truly was banned, but it does not do as much good if time is not taken to think about the children and minorities this will hurt. In order to rectify the impact of banning books, you need to consider what is being taken away and the consequences of denying a student that resource. Banning a book is not going to stop kids from learning the information contained within it, rather they are going to learn it from a source that was not intended for young audiences, which can be incredibly damaging. Not only does it expose children to a new sense of trauma and hurt, but it teaches them their identity is not important and that can have generational impacts that will negatively impact every facet of the world around them.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Take Aways & "George"

 The novel, George , offered tells the story of a young 'man' who felt that he did not fit into who he was; he saw himself as a young lady. While reading this novel, I noticed that this was the first piece of literature I have EVER read that even touched on this subject. To me,  George is a story about compassion, bravery, and accepting yourself & others-- all critical and key ideas in Middle and High School literature. However, this novel is continuously banned--which makes me wonder, 'how would you feel as a child who felt they had gender dysphoria or identified as non-binary or cis-gender and your school was fighting to ban a book like George '. Or, imagine if George (the character) learned his school was trying to ban a book like this? In George, the readers can see a clear change in the character once he sees that his principal is a supporter of transgender--but imagine if your school principal/administrator was trying to ban a book like George.  Not only is t...
Read more

Ringel

     While reading Ringel’s article, “How Banning Books Marginalizes Children,” a quote really struck me: “More broadly, keeping books about certain types of children or experiences out of libraries or putting them on separate shelves perpetuates a troubling vision of a sheltered American childhood that in fact has rarely existed” (Ringel 4-5). By telling American children that their experiences and lives are not valid or appropriate, we run the risk of making them even more excluded than they already feel. Keeping the books that deal with relevant life experiences out of libraries and on separate shelves is troubling. Even as a twenty-year-old, when I look in the LGBTQ+ section of Barnes and Noble, I barely feel safe around my family. They question why I am even looking in that section to begin with, telling me that it is a sin to read these types of books and that they will "turn me gay." The fact that it is separated allows for more marginalization and could possibly o...
Read more
 Faith Tyranski Dr. Ellis Banned Books  Blog Post  Ringel on Banning Books Throughout this semester, our class has been developing a working storyline, which details how books come to be banned, but moreover why people actively seek to ban books. One reoccurring part of our discussions centered around how parents or school administrators seek to ban books in their children's libraries or even books that are specifically targeted towards children. Ringel notes that "since the inception of the American children’s literature industry in the 1820s, publishers have had to grapple with the question of who their primary audience should be," and our class expanded on this idea, to incorporate the factor of maturity and autonomy. Building upon that initial claim by Ringel has enabled us to understand the banning of books as going beyond trying to segregate books based on target audiences, but rather as an attempt to halt progression, awareness, and systemic change.  When...
Read more